Connect
To Top


Can you lift light and still make muscle gains?


A long-standing tenet in bodybuilding is that if you want to promote muscular hypertrophy, or muscle size gains, you need to train heavy, using lower reps. Conversely, training with lighter weights will “tone” muscles, but isn’t effective for promoting gains in muscular size and strength. Much of this is based on a physiological principle called the Muscle fiber recruitment hierarchy. This principle states that the body activates only as many muscle fibers as possible to produce movement, beginning with the slow-twitch, or type-1 muscle fibers. As these fibers fatigue (and fatigue is the key word here, as we shall see), other muscle fibers, namely types 2-a and 2-b, also known as fast-twitch muscle fibers, are brought into play. What activates these fast-twitch fibers are neuromuscular connections. Simply put, when enough resistance is placed on the muscle, a signal is sent to the cerebellum section of the brain requesting more neural input to the muscle fibers in order to recruit the type-2 fibers. For years, it was thought that to recruit the type 2B muscle fibers required a greater neural input, and the best way to do this was to increase the intensity level of the imposed stress on the fibers. The best way to do this was to lift heavy. Indeed, most exercise physiology textbooks say that the fast-twitch type-2 muscle fibers are the fibers most amenable to gains in muscle size and strength. Type-1 slow-twitch fibers are more related to endurance, and would be activated with lower intensity exercise, such as when doing endurance activity, or when using lighter weights for higher reps. Again, it was thought that the body won’t recruit the type-2 fibers unless it was necessary. But note that the type-2 fibers can also be brought into play when the type-1 fibers become fatigued, for whatever reason.

Bodybuilders had larger muscles because of a selective hypertrophy of type 2B fast-twitch muscle fibers, and they achieved this through lifting heavy weights. But in recent years, this notion has come into question. As I reported in an Ironman magazine article a while ago, muscle biopsies of champion bodybuilders showed that they had a preponderance of type 2A fast-twitch muscle fibers, rather than the expected type 2B fibers. Type 2A fibers are considered an intermediate fiber, having characteristics of both type 1 and type 2 fibers. What this pointed to was that the typical bodybuilding workout of doing higher reps, averaging 8-12 per set, would likely produce better muscle gains compared to doing lower reps with heavier weight.While many powerlifters and Olympic weightlifters undeniably are strong, many don’t show the level of muscle hypertrophy that you would expect considering their chronic heavy lifting training routines, which usually involve heavy weights and low reps.

Occlusion training, which involves training with an impediment to blood flow, such as wearing an inflatable cuff while training, has been shown in several studies to produce significant gains in muscle size despite using light weights. Various reasons are offered to explain this effect, but the main mechanism seems to be an increase in localized fatigue products produced in the muscle as a result of the impeded blood flow. This increased fatigue, in turn, is interpreted by the brain as a call to recruit the type-2 muscle fibers, which result in the muscle gains apparent following this type of exercise. I also reported on another study, in which subjects lifted light weights, but under high tension, meaning that they did the exercises slower than normal, and forcefully contracted the trained muscles during every rep. Again, despite using weights only equivalent to 20% of one rep-maximum, which is very light, the subjects made gains in muscle size comparable to that achieved through lifting far heavier weights. The deciding factor here was again the level of local muscle fatigue produced in the trained muscle, which not only fully activated the type-2 fibers, but also promoted a greater release of anabolic hormones, such as growth hormone and IGF-1, which are stimulated by locallly produced muscle fatigue factors, such as increased lactic acid in the muscle.

In the latest study, 15 men, average age, 21, all of whom had at least 6 months of training experience, and had trained at least three times a week 6 months prior to the start of the study, did 4 sets of one-legged extensions using differing training protocols. These protocols were as follows:

1) 90% of one-rep maximum weight to failure (heavy weight)

2) 30% of one-rep maximum matched in reps and load to #1

3) 30% of one-rep maximum done to failure (light)

The scientists conducting the study calculated various rates of protein synthesis in the trained muscle, measuring both contractile protein synthesis and connective tissue or structural muscle protein synthesis. Increased muscle protein synthesis is directly related to increased gains in muscle size and strength, particularly the contractile proteins. The study results showed that the light weight to failure style (#3) was more effective at increasing muscle protein synthesis compared to #1, or high load, heavy weight. The light training to failure produced a level of muscle protein synthesis that was similar to that of the heavy load 4 hours after exercise, but it was sustained for 24 hours after training only in the light weight to failure training. The study authors suggest that the increased volume of training produced by the lighter weight to failure study resulted in more muscle fatigue, and more positively affected the amplitude of the muscle synthesis process. Only the #3 style of training produced sustained increases in the muscle protein synthesis rate of all proteins found in muscle: contractile, connective tissue, and mitochondrial. This means in simple terms that this style of training may be capable of increasing muscle size, strength, and even endurance simultaneously. The total number of completed reps was 94 in group #3; 19 in #1; and 62 in #2. The greater number of reps in #3 appeared to promote a greater activity of several muscle protein synthesis signaling factors. Group#3 also showed higher indicators of signaling factors for stimulation of muscle satellite cell activity, which is important for promoting muscle size and strength gains.

The authors suggest this information could be useful for prescribing exercise for those who are injured or too old to lift heavy weights.They point out that people over age 70 show an anabolic resistance to weight-training, meaning that they don’t show any significant increases in muscle protein synthesis following weight-training. This resistance,however, can be overcome by increasing the volume of exercise in the aged. This jives with the findings of this new study, which suggests that lifting lighter, but doing reps to muscle failure, is capable of fully turning on the muscle protein synthesis machinery of the body. The key is to induce enough fatigue in the muscle to kick-start the muscle protein synthesis reactions. And according to this study, it can be done by using lighter weights that feature higher reps to failure (reps in the study averaged 34 reps per set  in the light weight to failure sessions). I believe that a key element of these findings is that even in the light weight group, each set was done to muscular failure, no matter how many reps that took.  Just lifting light weights and not training to failure won’t do diddly squat in promoting muscle gains, since it won’t activate the muscle protein synthesis signaling factors that play a central role in producing muscle gains.

Burd, M, et al. Low-load high volume resistance exercise stimulates muscle protein synthesis more than high-load low volume resistance exercise in young men.Plus One 2010;5:e12033.

Learn the truth about various anabolic supplements in my e-book, Natural Anabolics, available at jerrybrainum.com.

9 Comments

  1. Doug Brignole

    August 14, 2010 at 12:36 am

    Hey Jerry, this is very interesting information. And very useful as well, especially for those – as you said – who are unable to lift heavier weights, and for those (trainers) who train clients who can’t lift heavy weights (usually due to an injury or joint issues).

    Ironically, it takes more “guts” or courage to take a high-rep set to absolute failure, because the lactic acid burn can be excruciating. But this study certainly helps explain why some bodybuilders (like Tom Platz, with his amazing leg development, built with his very high-reps squats) produce enormous hypertrophy from high reps.

  2. Jerry Brainum

    August 14, 2010 at 5:12 am

    Doug: I agree with you concerning the utility of this information in relation to those unable to train with heavy weights. I hadn’t thought about Platz’s use of high rep squats, but I do indeed recall him telling me that this type of high rep, high intensity training was responsible for the humongous legs that he developed (along with some genetic predispositions, of course). And when I think about it, it also explains how some other BBs got huge without lifting heavy, and it’s more than just drug usage, as many attribute it to. I’ve tried a version of this, and it’s not easy, despite the use of considerably lighter weights. I aimed for about 25 reps per set to failure, but I was only about to do about one or two sets like this. By the third set, I barely got about 12 reps. I experienced a huge level of muscle fatigue, just as was discussed in the study I wrote about in the blog. Another aspect of this to consider is that it offers hope for those of us over 40 who no longer can lift heavy for one reason or another. I am in that category, since the weights that I am using these days are about the same that I used for warmups just a few years ago. Based on this study, I’m going to reduce my weights and try to do higher reps to failure and see what happens. At least my fragile connective tissue won’t take a beating.

  3. Florian Spurling

    August 15, 2010 at 2:17 pm

    Dear Mr. Brainum,

    thank you for this very informative article. The following passage has caught my immediate interest:

    “I also reported on another study, in which subjects lifted light weights, but under high tension, meaning that they did the exercises slower than normal, and forcefully contracted the trained muscles during every rep. Again, despite using weights only equivalent to 20% of one rep-maximum, which is very light, the subjects made gains in muscle size comparable to that achieved through lifting far heavier weights.”

    For the past week I have done just what is described above, and it felt really different from my regular training. I will definitely continue training this way for a while longer so that I can evaluate the effects on my physique and strength levels.

    Could you please point me to the previous article in which you discuss the “high tension training study” in greater detail?

    Greetings from Germany,
    Florian Spurling

  4. Dr. Michael Chiccone

    August 16, 2010 at 8:42 am

    Looks like Arthur Jones was right again. The real key is to train to failure even if the reps take you out of the 8 to 12 range. Of all the elements of HIT it seems that the “failure” that is pushed by all of them is the essential ingredient. The other two, brief and infrequent can be regulated by the BB to fit his or her genetics and whatever drugs may be taken, but getting to failure, even with lighter weights is essential. Great article Jerry.

  5. Jerry Brainum

    August 16, 2010 at 7:45 pm

    Florian, I’m sorry but I wrote that information that you asked about in an Ironman article a while ago. I don’t have the reference or even the issue available, so I can’t help you with that.

  6. Jerry Brainum

    August 16, 2010 at 7:54 pm

    In a personal communication with the lead author of the study described above, Nicholas Burd of McMaster University, I asked about whether using a light weight, high intensity style of training would contribute to strength gains, as well as muscle mass. He told me that because gaining strength involves a large neurological component, you would need to lift heavier loads than was used in the study to make significant gains in muscle strength. As for overload, Burd said that you should adjust the load to aim for 20-25 reps to muscular failure. He also noted that different exercises will require a slightly different percentage of one-rep maximum training load. The exercise used in the study, one-legged extensions, is very ischemic, and hastens the recruitment of type-2 muscle fibers. For other exercises, you may need a higher one-rep max percentage to get the same effect.

  7. Florian Spurling

    August 17, 2010 at 2:09 pm

    Dear Mr. Brainum,

    Thank you very much for getting back to me.

    Training muscles by the use of dynamic tension is a fascinating concept which has been made use of in various systems for physical training (martial arts, yoga, chi kung, the Atlas course), and I would love modern sports scientists to take a closer look at this idea, separating fact from fiction.

  8. Ron

    August 20, 2010 at 7:50 am

    Dear all,

    When I look at the gymnastics than I see also enormous muscles. They do the exercises almost every day without any lifts. They exercise as long as the can control the exercise. So this is maybe what we can compare with lifting light weights.

    Ronald

  9. Jeff Rhodes

    August 23, 2010 at 8:22 pm

    Jerry,
    Great article. Pavel’s training is hurting my forearms. I am going to switch to high reps for awhile and see if I can get gains with the lighter weights.
    Jeff

You must be logged in to post a comment Login

Leave a Reply

More in Blog Post

  • Get A Good Workout with Mike Rashid

    Muscle sensation Mike Rashid, whose motto is “Train Your Mind as Hard as You Train Your Body,” explains his shoulder massifier step...

    Cindy MamJuly 16, 2018
  • Why Your Big Toe Is Your Key To Great Calves!

    If you’re looking to really build your calves, this one little piece of advice will help tremendously. Yet you rarely, if...

    Nick NilssonApril 6, 2016
  • Create Big-Ass Shoulders With Mike Rashid

    His motto “Train Your Mind as Hard as You Train Your Body,” may test your muscles and your mind.

    Iron Man MagazineMarch 21, 2016
  • The Workout and Happiness

    Happy New Year—a perennial cliché!  Can anything or anybody make you happy? To paraphrase a well-known line from Shakespeare’s Julius Caesar,...

    John BalikFebruary 11, 2015
  • New Year Resolutions

    January first, the birth of a new year.  Time to reflect on the old and plan for the new! Historically, January...

    John BalikJanuary 15, 2015
  • Do You Know Squat ?

    Have you heard any of the following recommendations? “Don’t let your knees go over your toes when you squat, because it’s...

    Doug BrignoleDecember 30, 2014
  • Another Rewarding Olympia Weekend

    A couple of weeks ago I was at the Mr. Olympia competition, the 50th rendition of that iconic event. What started...

    John BalikDecember 15, 2014
  • Muscle Beach Breakfast Club

    I have been a part of Muscle Beach Venice since competing there in the mid ’60s. Much has changed in the...

    John BalikNovember 15, 2014
  • The Science Behind My 2 Week Body Transformation into a Mythological Minotaur

    Sometimes getting in shape can mean perfect timing.  In order to make a 2 week body transformation, science can play a...

    curtis.fisherNovember 14, 2014